19 replies to this topic

[El DaN]

i think yes its 2 long 2 boot all

[Dc]

yeah, but there should be a code thing like with /reset

[Xsjado]

I agree, it takes like 2 hours depending on the members in clan, to remove them from clan great idea i support it

[frosty]

i think the chair man souldnt be able to jsut put it on the forum for sale i think they sould frist have to have a metting with staff frist and by giveing them a reason for wanting to sell thier clan cuase a clan is orgnaly build to be supportof and to build leader ship and as a chairman u sould never sell ur clan no matter what u sould build ur clan to be come the best of the best not quit and give up and throw in the towel it sould be up to the founders as well as the leaders to vote thats why thopses postions r made for a clan..

[jurian]

yup supported.

[Thunderja]

Didn't support. Selling a clan is too often someone selling out for easy cash.... make them work for it.

[Ryuku]

/nod thunderja

[Quartz]

i'm gonna have to go with thunderja here and say make them work for it. besides boot by position works just fine :

[Malavon]

Didn't support. Selling a clan is too often someone selling out for easy cash.... make them work for it.

They already have worked for the cash that they used to buy the clan house with.

Supported.

[Lady_Maha]

Didn't support. Selling a clan is too often someone selling out for easy cash.... make them work for it.

They already have worked for the cash that they used to buy the clan house with.

Supported.

And a lot of times they haven't. I don't see much work in watching clan members donate. I know if I was ever forced to sell Broken, just about every member I have would get a more or less decent amount because they all donated. I feel I have no right to claim it all as mine simply because I had the genius idea to /clan create Broken.

[Momba]

Pretty lame idea. I mean if your going to take and sell something your members worked so hard to help you build I say that the chairperson should have to endure each and every crit being booted from the clan one by one. That was for those that just build clans to get others to donate and sell later can atleast say they earned it...lol

[Squee]

/clan remove [position] works fine.

[sayadin]

put a timer on the code. Make it to where once the Chairman/woman first enter "/clan clear" or whatever the code may be, set a timer of 1 week. So it will give the clan some time for its members to talk to their chairman/woman about selling the clan. And when the time is up then the whole clan is empty except for the chairman/woman. But within that week of timing, the chairman/woman may change its mind so they could enter in "/clan enter" and the timer will go away and no one will be booted.

[Squee]

If they're that keen on selling the clan, they'll use /clan remove [position]. If they are seriously considering selling the clan, they'll /memo members (or whatever the command is).

[Gaddy]

Pretty lame idea. I mean if your going to take and sell something your members worked so hard to help you build I say that the chairperson should have to endure each and every crit being booted from the clan one by one. That was for those that just build clans to get others to donate and sell later can atleast say they earned it...lol

I agree.

[sayadin]

maybe there could be a way to keep count on how much a member donates to the clan. kinda like a receipt or something. so in the end when the chairperson does sell the clan the donater(s) of the clan will recieve their percentage from their previous donations.. for example

sayadin donated 200,000 gold coin to the clan.

1 month later the chairperson sells the clan.

sayadin recieves 150,000 gold coins from the sold clan.

in other words the server keeps the receipt and once the clan is sold all members who donated will get 75% of it back. So the members who worked hard for the gold get their share and it will stop chairpersons from taking the money from those who did most of the work.

[El DaN]

maybe there could be a way to keep count on how much a member donates to the clan. kinda like a receipt or something. so in the end when the chairperson does sell the clan the donater(s) of the clan will recieve their percentage from their previous donations.. for example

/nod
that is fair, a member shud get some money for donating but the chairman/woman also has a right because they made the clan

[Lady_Maha]

The flaw in that theory is that people sell their crits. What if someone donated 2 years ago, but the crit he donated with is now sold? Will that mean the lucky buyer will get the share of the donation?

It simply depends on the chairman/woman to be fair about sharing any profits coming from a clan sale. Ideally the clan simply won't get sold. People donate to a clan for the support they get from it, not to save up gold and get 75% of it back later.

[sayadin]

actually... it will only effect to those still in the clan. you could change the name of a crit or something by doing a code to let the server know that the crit is no longer in the clan and that another crit is taking over the collection if the clan is sold.

and who would give up 100k-500k??? its called greed. when you give another person some gold or a crap load of it, and tell them not to spend one piece. which of course they will spend a small portion of it and say they will pay you back.. if you are able to find someone to hold your 30k of gold without spending one gold piece then they are the more trustworthy person.

not everthing is fair in life. thats why we have challenges